‘Strategic Modernization’ project details offered, with rollout planned for spring

By MARTY LEVINE

Pitt’s “Strategic Modernization” effort, set to hit the decision-making phase this spring, was previewed at Staff Council’s Nov. 18 meeting by Chief Financial Officer Dwayne Pinkney: Pitt is “thinking about where the work is done, and how the work is done, and by whom the work is done, so that we're best prepared to plan for success. We're also prepared to think through refining processes and … about the work that remains: what is priority work and what work might need to be de-prioritized going forward, and/or things that we would no longer do or support.”

Dwayne PinkneyPinkney, executive senior vice chancellor for Administration and Finance, and Don Elliott, senior vice provost for Budget and Institutional Effectiveness, laid out the reasons for the endeavor, which began last spring. “This work,” said Pinkney, “has been really the result of our recognition as an institution of the moment that we're in and also as a real reflection on the pressures that not just Pitt faces but all of higher ed faces, and our effort to get our arms around the challenges that we face, the headwinds, and to think very strategically about opportunities that we can take as an institution to better position ourselves to address these headwinds, to extend our capacity where we need to, to be more efficient where we have to be …”

Those challenges, the pair said, include: terminations of federal research awards and proposed cuts to funding indirect costs; the NCAA antitrust settlement that has resulted in universities paying some student athletes; the annual decline in the number of new high school graduates that is projected to continue through 2041; the dip in public views of the value of higher ed; a limit on how much tuition can rise; new limits proposed for student financial aid; and steep increases in healthcare costs for employers.

Overall, they said, revenues are decreasing while expenses are rising. The former include limited student housing capacity, decreasing enrollment at regional campuses, and flat state appropriations since 2019. Increased expenses include employee pay increases not covered by tuition increases; a larger campus; greater student services costs; and employee numbers rising faster than student numbers. Since 2021, Pitt has added the full-time equivalents of about 1,500 employee (up 11%) and $400 million in compensation (up 27%) to serve the full-time equivalents of about 1,500 more students (up 5%). 

Pinkney pointed out that “over the past five years, higher education headwinds and periods of disruption have worn Pitt’s [positive] margins” – the percentage of funds left over after expenses. He presented a graph that showed Pitt’s margin of revenue over expenses at 1% in fiscal year 2024, 1.3% in fiscal year 2025, and 0% in fiscal year 2026, with deficits in this margin projected to go from -.8% to -2.6% between next fiscal year and 2030. “Sustaining long-term financial stability will require more than just incremental cuts,” read a slide in their presentation. “As external pressures intensify, the university will need to responsibly right-size for current and future needs.”

“That is not a a pretty picture,” Pinkney said, “and I'm sure that you've all heard the saying, ‘no margin, no mission,’ and that is exactly what this picture portrays – that as operating margin evaporates we have very little to nothing left to invest in continuing and certainly new investments in the University.”

The three goals of strategic modernization, the pair said, are thus to “position the university for sustained success and competitiveness within an increasingly complex and competitive higher education landscape; establish a more modern, flexible and simplified administrative and academic operating model to better support the University's mission and improve agility to advance priorities; and align the University around a focused set of high-value, mission-aligned opportunities that address near-term financial pressure while strengthening long-term institutional resilience.”

Elliott noted that the firm of Deloitte is assisting in the information gathering phases of this effort; stakeholders have been interviewed and data from HR, operations and other offices have been studied; 1,600 employees recently took a Pitt-wide survey to contribute their views to the project; and it is being overseen by representatives from all over Pitt, including Staff Council. “From the work that's been completed today,” he said, “the project team has identified four emerging opportunity areas across Pitt with greatest potential to improve efficiencies and effectiveness as well as service delivery.” These include: 

  • intentionally designing core back office administrative services with more standardized processes and more and better use of technology; 
  • controlling spending on goods and services; 
  • evaluating the capacity of the academic delivery model; 
  • rationalizing the physical footprint by making better use of Pitt buildings and spaces and addressing deferred maintenance.

The pair’s slide presentation offered details about how each area might be implemented:

  • administrative services: “Reorganize staff performing those functions into accountable teams, institute position controls to ensure savings from the new operating model are realized, and leverage AI to automate workflows and drive efficiency.”
  • controlling spending: “Building enforcement mechanisms that redirect off-contract spend to negotiated agreements, strengthen travel-program adoption, and modernize disparate and legacy systems within the IT system footprint.”
  • capacity of the academic delivery model: “Alignment between credentials and workforce needs; faculty composition and workload expectations; and low-enrolled courses and course capacity”
  • rationalizing the physical footprint: “Consolidate and standardize underutilized space, tighten capital project governance and spending controls and address the deferred maintenance backlog driving up long-term operating costs.”

Pinkney added, “I want to just note that these are areas of focus for analysis but leadership at this point is not making a decision on any of them.”

Asked how the long-running compensation modernization effort by Human Resources and the recently offered Voluntary Early Retirement Program aligned with this latest project, Pinkney said: “These are two parallel streams, and they are not specifically linked at this point in time. Logically, one can imagine that as the picture becomes more clear around the VERP and the impact of the VERP, that strategic modernization will be one of the ways that we're able to address some of the challenges that might result as a result of changes in staffing …”

He also noted that, while standardized University-wide processes may be instituted, unit-specific needs will still be addressed: “If the standard process isn't sufficient then clearly there would be a way to accommodate what a unit needs that would just go above and beyond the standard process.”

Addressing a question about how Pitt might increase its revenue, Pinkney said: “While I wish that revenue generation was something that we could perform magic around and … we could identify alternative sources of revenue, what we have to ask ourselves as an institution is what things are we prepared to do more of and or less of … The Deloitte work will shed light on where opportunities are for us to enhance our revenue and to control and mitigate or decrease our expenses; that is at the heart of the work that we're doing.”

He also emphasized that “nothing that we're doing in this work around strategic modernization is designed or will detract from the work that we continue to do” with Pitt’s surrounding community. … We're focused on supporting small and local businesses and building out a really robust and healthy vendor ecosystem and in our community engagement efforts.” 

Elliott noted that Pitt is also instituting “a common change management methodology across the University” and offering a class through the University Center for Teaching and Learning on the subject: “Please sign up for that course when it gets put in place,” he said.

Pinkney said he believed Pitt would “remain an employer of choice” for its staff, and that “our ability to support enrollment growth and to sustain it in the current environment, with the demographics being what they are, can only be helped when we're working in the most effective way. We think that these efforts and the recommendations that we get, that we decide to prioritize … will help support the underpinning for effective mission, and enrollment is of course a part of that. … I don't think that anything we're doing is wasting our time and/or effort. I think this is preparing us for a competitive environment that we're already in, that's only going to get more competitive.”

 

Marty Levine is a staff writer for the University Times. Reach him at martyl@pitt.edu or 412-758-4859.

Have a story idea or news to share? Share it with the University Times.

Follow the University Times on Facebook.