Authorship dispute-resolution committee offers ‘final advice’ when other approaches fall short

By SHANNON O. WELLS

When a departmental dean referred a researcher who disputed the authorship credit on a project to Bill Yates in August, he knew just the path to take from there. 

“They only wanted middle authorship. They said, ‘I provided very extensive input into study design and analysis.’ And then I took that to the committee,” said Yates, vice chancellor for Research Protections.

Formed last summer, “the committee” focuses on resolving authorship disputes when other means have seemingly been exhausted.   

“They wanted the evidence that this individual had. And the complainant had lots of emails and other documentation that they had discussed the study many times with the lead author and also played a notable role in data interpretation,” he added. “… There was … written documentation that the complainant had done a lot in terms of getting the study off the ground.”

The authorship committee agreed that the complainants should be listed as a middle author. 

“Ultimately, the authors accepted the findings. They wrote their paper up. They submitted it. So, I think this was a success so far,” Yates said. “The only issue is the fact that we've tried to publicize this committee so far in our newsletters and other venues, but I don't think a lot of people know about it yet.”

Yates provided an update of the authorship committee in a presentation to Faculty Assembly at its Nov. 4 meeting in Posvar Hall. He first introduced the concept at a Senate Research Committee meeting in May. 

The impetus came from a two-or-three-times a month trend of Pitt individuals asking Susan Sesack, Pitt’s research integrity officer, and her associates to help sort out differences related to authorship of research papers and projects. 

As Yates explained, that’s not really the department’s job. 

“They help deal with other issues, and they don't have the bandwidth to do this,” he said. “What we did is (refer) people back to their department chair or their dean and say, ‘Talk to somebody responsible in your school to help out.’ And that's not always satisfactory to both the authors, and often the chairs and the deans didn't like that responsibility either.”

Discussing this disconnect, Yates and Rob Rutenbar, senior vice chancellor for research, decided that a standing committee to help researchers resolve their differences “would be useful.”

“This committee is not involved unless somebody comes to us and asks for help. Its output is going to be advice. It is not a binding resolution,” Yates said. “It’s just advice back to the authors to help them resolve their differences.”

Rather than research misconduct such as “fabrication, falsification of data or plagiarism,” the committee focuses on helping to resolve authorship differences in a non-binding approach. 

Taking responsibility 

Rutenbar and Yates, who serves as committee chair, looked at other institutions to establish benchmarks. 

“A number of universities, like Duke, have a dedicated committee like we put together,” Yates explained. “A number of other schools have a structured process with escalation to a responsible official. It's very common for schools to have an authorship resolution process.”

They also reviewed criteria for authorship, which they found are “very similar across disciplines.” 

“First of all, anyone who's listed as an author needs to make a substantial contribution to the design of the work or to data acquisition, analysis or interpretation. And I think the critical word there is ‘substantial,’ and that's where people often get hung up as whether or not somebody's contribution was substantial enough to be an author,” he noted. 

That individual also has to be involved in either drafting, reviewing or revising the paper. 

“They have to give final approval to the scholarly project, and at the end, they have to agree to be accountable for the work as well. I think across disciplines, anyone who meets these four criteria should be listed as an author on a publication.”

He and Rutenbar also established that certain cross-disciplinary factors are not permissible. 

“Ghost authorship, leaving somebody out that should be included as an author, that's not appropriate. Gift authorship — which used to be pretty common in the old days (when you would) put your department chair on every paper — that's now considered unethical.”

Same goes for purchased authorship, where somebody sponsors a study in which their only relationship is giving money for its execution. “And they want to be an author just because of that. That's considered unethical.” 

Across disciplines, every scholarly project requires a lead author who takes overall responsibility for the work. 

“Often this is called the ‘corresponding author,’” he said, which “basically establishes the author list and order” gets agreement from all authors about their order, and then solicits all their approval for the final work to be submitted.”

As with most scholarly endeavors, planning ahead is beneficial for avoiding authorship disputes.  

“I think it's a very good practice that as you start a project, you start discussing with all the people involved in the project the authorship and the order of the authors. That should start even before you start your project, recognizing, of course, that roles can change,” Yates noted. “Science (and) scholarly endeavors are not always predictable. 

“You may need to bring in other people over time, and people need to keep talking about the authorship or order during the execution of a project.”

Therefore, having a written authorship agreement in which everyone involved understands their role and what order their name will be in terms of the paper’s author is “often helpful.”

Range of disciplines

In absence of such foresight and effort, the new committee is what Yates called a “last ditch” option for those who “can't resolve” concerns on their own.”

The process starts by approaching the lead author to discuss the matter. If that doesn’t work, the concerned party attempts to find an “ombudsman, like a senior faculty member,” to help serve as a neutral conversation facilitator. 

“And if all else fails, then this committee is available to provide the final advice to the group,” Yates explained. “Again, it's advice, and we only get involved if the authors request that we get involved.”

To accommodate a range of disciplines from across campus, the committee comprises faculty members from fields including clinical and basic science research, the professions, social sciences, humanities, and STEM (Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics). Two trainees also are there to provide their perspectives.

“Of course we have the chair that does most of the logistics,” he said. “And right now, the chair is me.”

Other schools and disciplines represented on the committee include: 

  • Engineering
  • Education
  • Law
  • Dietrich School of Arts and Sciences
  • Sociology, and
  • Chinese as second language. 

“We have a graduate student from Arts and Sciences on the committee, and then we have some people from the medical school, both from the clinical side and the basic-science side,” Yates noted. 

Noting the committee’s manageable workload of one case since August, he described a process in which a complainant completes an online intake form describing their concerns and what they've done to resolve the dispute, which goes to the chair.  

“I will call that individual, have a Zoom meeting and talk through their case, making sure that we have all the information that we initially need,” he said, “and also confirming that they tried to actually resolve the differences before they came to the committee.”

Yates presents that information to the committee, whose members may request more information such as written statements from others, the complainants, co-authors and others involved. 

“The one case that we've had, we've gotten statements from all the co-authors as well as the complainant. Based on all the evidence, we come out with our opinion about who should be an author and what the author order should be,” he said, emphasizing the decision’s non-binding nature. “It's advice to help the authors work through their problems. We give it to both the authors and their dean.”

A decision can be binding, however, if all authors approach the committee and say, “’Please resolve this. We will agree to what you tell us’ … But if all the authors don't tell us in advance that they want the committee's decision to be binding, it isn't. It's just advice.”

Making adjustments

He encourages anyone who wants the committee’s input to email him at byates@Pitt.edu and he will “point them to the right page,” or to visit the Office of Research Protection website’s section on Authorship Guidelines.  

Responding to a question about early-career faculty who feel they’re in a vulnerable position being reticent to draw attention to authorship issues, Yates said he’s “always willing to talk to people. People actually have approached me, and we've discussed this through. 

“One person who had left a lab said, ‘I think I should be on the paper, but the lead author is suggesting I have to read the paper and agree to its contents to be listed as an author.’ I told them, ‘Unfortunately, you do have to read the paper to be an author on it.’ So that resolved it pretty quickly.” 

If somebody is afraid of approaching the lead author, “we have a process,” he added. “We want people to try to work things out on their own, but they can always discuss this with me directly, and we will try to actually resolve their issues as best we can.”

Yates indicated he was open to changing the term “complainant” to “concerned party,” based on a suggestion from Lisa Parker, professor in the School of Public Health. 

He also was receptive to a suggestion from Tom Songer, assistant professor in the School of Public Health, to build on the committee’s “institutional knowledge” and provide guidance to future investigators and authors about common authorship-related scenarios, such as in the form of a website document. 

“We can certainly build that out … some webinars and other information to basically give people best practices on how they deal with these authorship situations,” Yates said. 

Songer also suggested looking into older websites where stipulations about the authors’ original intentions in sharing data may be lacking.

“For older databases, that may not be there,” Yates said of such stipulations. “I have to look into what the best strategy is per discipline. It's interesting as the committee discussed its first case how different disciplines are in terms of how they view authorship. It's quite diverse.”

 

Shannon O. Wells is a writer for the University Times. Reach him at shannonw@pitt.edu.

Have a story idea or news to share? Share it with the University Times.

Follow the University Times on Facebook.